英文论文审稿意见范文大全.docx

英文论文审稿意见范文大全

第一篇：英文论文审稿意见Thispaperaddressesanimportantandinterestingproblem-automaticallyidentifyingadultaccountsonSinaWeibo.Theauthorsproposetwosetsofbehaviorindicatorsforadultgroupsandaccounts,andfindthatadultgroupsandaccountshavedifferentbehavioraldistributionswithnon-adultgroupsandaccounts.Thenanovelrelation-basedmodel,whichconsiderstheinter-relationshipsamonggroups,inpidualaccountsandmessagesources,isappliedtoidentifyadultaccounts.Theexperimentalresultsshowthatcomparedwithstate-of-the-artmethods,theproposedmethodcanimprovetheperformanceofadultaccountidentificationonSinaWeibo.Overall,thearticleiswellorganizedanditspresentationisgood.However,someminorissuesstillneedtobeimproved:(1)TheauthorsshouldsummarizethemaincontributionsofthispaperinSection1.(2)InSection4.2,theauthorsmentionedthat“AgroupwillattainavalueveryclosetoonGACSifallitsaccountshaveentirelycopiedtheirowntexts,imagesorcontactinformation”.However,accordingtoEquation8,contactinformationisnotconsideredwhencomputingGACS.(3)InAlgorithm1onPg.17,itseemsthat“t=t+1”shouldbeaddedafterline6.(4)IsuggestthatthelimitationofthisworkshouldbediscussedinSection9.(5)Thereareafewtyposandgrammarerrorsinthispaper.第二篇：英文论文审稿意见汇总英文论文审稿意见汇总以下12点无轻重主次之分。每一点内容由总结性标题和代表性审稿人意见构成。1、目标和结果不清晰。ItisnotedthatyourmanuscriptneedscarefuleditingbysomeonewithexpertiseintechnicalEnglisheditingpayingparticularattentiontoEnglishgrammar,spelling,andsentencestructuresothatthegoalsandresultsofthestudyarecleartothereader.2、未解释研究方法或解释不充分。◆Ingeneral,thereisalackofexplanationofreplicatesandstatisticalmethodsusedinthestudy.◆Furthermore,anexplanationofwhytheauthorsdidthesevariousexperimentsshouldbeprovided.3、对于研究设计的rationale:Also,therearefewexplanationsoftherationaleforthestudydesign.4、夸张地陈述结论/夸大成果/不严谨：Theconclusionsareoverstated.Forexample,thestudydidnotshowifthesideeffectsfrominitialcopperburstcanbeavoidwiththepolymerformulation.5、对hypothesis的清晰界定：Ahypothesisneedstobepresented。6、对某个概念或工具使用的rationale/定义概念：Whatwastherationaleforthefilm/SBFvolumeratio?7